Market News & Analysis


Top Story

Barclays ‘challenges’ overshadow trading win

CEO Jes Staley opts for caution despite yet another vindication of his strategy

More apparent vindication for Jes Staley’s gambit of retaining a full-service investment bank to enable exposure to markets windfalls like the one that underpinned giant U.S. banks in the third quarter. Barclays, now the only large UK-domiciled lender with a Wall Street franchise on par with JPMorgan’s, reported a 17% income rise in the Corporate & Investment Bank division on the back of surprisingly robust bond and equity trading. CEO Staley called the unit’s quarterly performance in equity, debt capital markets and merger advisor, its best ever.

It’s difficult to downplay the sentiment, at least. The bank now has four consecutive trading beats in the bag. What’s more, the 15% rise in fixed income, currencies and commodity  (FICC) trading boosted the Markets unit’s income 13%, crushing the average 6.4% trading income advance reported by key Wall Street rivals.

The whole point of maintaining a strong investment banking (IB) footprint is that it’s supposed to be core to a transatlantic lending franchise, bringing synergistic benefits that would not be possible with a lighter approach to IB. The problem some investors have had with Staley’s strategy, including one Edward Bramson, activist, now seen off, was that Barclays’ IB hogs resources (around 50% of risk-weighted assets) whilst delivering mediocre returns. The Investment Bank’s key measure of returns, Return on Tangible Equity (RoTE) is now much improved from 2017’s 2.2%. IB RoTE ticked down to 9.3% in Q3, vs. Q2 2018’s 9.7%. But it remains close to the assumed cost of capital of around 10%.

The big question then – and it’s been the big question for successive quarters – concerns whether such improvements are sustainable. Investors’ historic view has been sceptical. Lloyds Banking Group’s balance is sheet is far smaller than Barclays’, yet LBG has a larger market cap. Barclay’s also trades at a discount to book value of some 40% relative to closely matched EU and North American rivals. There’s a sense that the Barclays story remains too complex to fully get on board with. Key performance details from the quarter moderate any notion that it was a rip-roaring one:

  • Broader Barclays International profit, excluding litigation and conduct charges still fell 4%, year-on-year
  • Credit card & payment returns joined CIB with declines
  • Equity trading income actually fell too; -11%, on what looks like a quarter-specific drop in derivatives activity
  • Barclays stake in Tradeweb added a £126m one-off gain to Markets (similar to that which U.S. stakeholder banks booked a couple of quarters ago)
  • The removal of Barclays’ Risk Weighted Assets floor following discussions with regulators, instantly removed £14bn in RWA. That inorganically lifted the ‘core capital’ CET1 ratio 60 basis points to 13.4%

Meanwhile, Jes Staley, is most cautious about Brexit exposed Barclays UK, where RoTE slid to 17.2% from the 18.9% a year ago. The “unquestionably more challenging” environment than a year ago, particularly “uncertainty around the UK. economy and the interest rate environment,” are behind Barclays’ assessment that 2019 and 2020 targets are now “more challenging” to achieve. That’s almost inviting investors to accept the 10% group return target by next year is out of reach. Given that it’s the key to sustainable profits, despite authentic progress, Barclays’ slow-to-no-growth prospects and discount will remain.

The stock rose as much as 3% initially on Friday though eventually trimmed that move to less than 1%. Over the year, BARC stock is now close to closing the gap to the best-performing shares of large European lenders. The group’s comments and a careful look at progress over the last 9 months strongly suggest that outperformance by the stock into the year end is unlikely.


Normalised: Big European bank stocks – year to date

Source: Bloomberg/City Index


Disclaimer

This report is intended for general circulation only. It should not be construed as a recommendation, or an offer (or solicitation of an offer) to buy or sell any financial products. The information provided does not take into account your specific investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs. Before you act on any recommendation that may be contained in this report, independent advice ought to be sought from a financial adviser regarding the suitability of the investment product, taking into account your specific investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs.

GAIN Capital Singapore Pte. Ltd., may distribute reports produced by its respective foreign entities or affiliates within the GAIN Capital group of companies or third parties pursuant to an arrangement under Regulation 32C of the Financial Advisers Regulations. Where the report is distributed to a person in Singapore who is not an accredited investor, expert investor or an institutional investor (as defined in the Securities Futures Act), GAIN Capital Singapore Pte. Ltd. accepts legal responsibility to such persons for the contents of the report only to the extent required by law. Singapore recipients should contact GAIN Capital Singapore Pte. Ltd. at 6826 9988 for matters arising from, or in connection with the report.

In the case of all other recipients of this report, to the extent permitted by applicable laws and regulations neither GAIN Capital Singapore Pte. Ltd. nor its associated companies will be responsible or liable for any loss or damage incurred arising out of, or in connection with, any use of the information contained in this report and all such liability is hereby expressly disclaimed. No representation or warranty is made, express or implied, that the content of this report is complete or accurate.

GAIN Capital Singapore Pte. Ltd. is not under any obligation to update this report.

Trading CFDs and FX on margin carries a high level of risk that may not be suitable for some investors. Consider your investment objectives, level of experience, financial resources, risk appetite and other relevant circumstances carefully. The possibility exists that you could lose some or all of your investments, including your initial deposits. If in doubt, please seek independent expert advice. Visit cityindex.com.sg for the complete Risk Disclosure Statement.

Important Notice:

Cryptocurrencies are not legal tender currency and trading of derivatives on Cryptocurrencies are currently not covered under any regulatory regime in Singapore. Consequently, investors should be aware they do not have protection under the Securities and Futures Act (Cap. 289). Please ensure that you are fully aware of the risks.